Before I get into it: I’m not trying to bash anyone. I’m not naming names, and I’m not trying to ruin anyone’s reputation. But I need to get this out, because other writers need to see it before they say yes to something similar.
Here’s what happened.
The Invitation
A fellow Christian writer sent me a DM on Substack. He was pulling together a small team of creators for growth strategies. I was in. That kind of collaboration is normal here, and I’ve done it before. I recently teamed up with Christian Historian on this publication.
Then he sent the list of ideas, and I felt sick.
Someone put real thought into this. It was clever, layered, and impressive in how far it had been optimized. Just optimized in the wrong direction. Here’s the message, copied straight from my inbox:
I’m talking to around 10 other writers right now… the ideas we are kicking around include the following:
Substack Native Cross-Promotion
Recommendations Exchange: Suggest each other’s newsletters during the sign-up flow so new readers can subscribe in one click.
In-Feed Restacks: Share partner posts to your Substack Notes feed with a quick one-sentence takeaway.
Shared Resource Sections: Add a short “Recommended Reading” link block to your About page or email footers.
Shared Marketing & Distribution
Joint Lead Magnet Bundles: Pool existing digital downloads into a shared offer for new subscribers.
Cross-Mention Link Drops: Include a quick “Reads of the Week” link section at the bottom of regular posts.
Shared Social Threads: Post social media roundups highlighting partner insights to drive cross-platform traffic.
Audience Pooling & List Strategies
Joint Cross-Publication (Network Brand): Launch a shared, lightweight Substack publication where all partner creators hold admin rights. Import existing lists into this central hub (with reader consent) to publish periodic roundups, instantly exposing every participating creator to the combined audience.
Direct List Swaps & Imports: Send dedicated email blasts introducing a partner’s newsletter to your list, or use Substack’s subscriber import feature to add opting-in segments from cross-promotional campaigns directly into each other’s databases.
Read that last section again. That’s ten strangers agreeing to treat each other’s subscribers like shared inventory.
Here’s where the line actually is.
Where the Line Actually Is
A joint publication with another creator? Fine. I run one myself. You collaborate, you cross-promote, you each keep your own list, and nobody touches the other person’s subscribers without them asking to be there.
Direct list imports is a different story entirely. And “reader consent” is carrying a lot in that sentence, because someone subscribing to Writer A’s newsletter never agreed to end up on Writer B’s list, or Writer C’s, or whichever of the ten people in that group chat decides to import a “segment.”
This is a big problem. Actually, it’s two problems stacked on top of each other:
CAN-SPAM law requires that people who get your marketing emails actually opted in — to you, specifically. Being on someone else’s list doesn’t count, no matter what consent language gets slapped on the pitch.
Substack’s own terms prohibit importing subscriber lists without direct, explicit permission. Get reported, and your account can be suspended or banned. The platform you built your audience on? Gone.
And underneath both of those: not one line in that entire pitch mentioned pastoral care, compassion, or anything resembling a Christian virtue. Just growth tactics dressed up as fellowship.
The Uncomfortable Truth
I’m also sad to say that one of the people behind this is well known on this platform. Climbing the ranks, getting the praise, and seen as one of the “good ol boys.”
I’ve spent enough time in these networking circles to tell you what’s really going on behind some of them: a lot of well regarded creators are dazzled by growth, money, and the praise of other people — and it shows in what they’re willing to propose when they think no one outside is watching. The recommendations, the restacks, the constant collaboration invites? A good chunk of that isn’t generosity. It’s people who’ve figured out exactly what the algorithm rewards, and are performing “helping each other” because performing it pays.
So if you get an invite like this, don’t assume good intentions just because the word “Christian” is attached to it. Ask what happens to your list. Ask what “consent” actually means in their plan. And if the answer involves your subscribers ending up somewhere they never signed up for, walk away from the group chat, no matter how many “good guys” are sitting in it.
I’m all for getting paid for your writing and growing on Substack, but when you become this obsessed with it, you completely lose sight of it.
Lastly, be aware subscribers. Not everyone who portrays themselves as a “good person” is actually a good person. And if you see a big collaboration coming up with other Christian Writers, just know that there isn’t good intentions behind it.
2 Corinthians 11: 13-14 —
"For such people are false apostles, deceitful workers, masquerading as apostles of Christ. And no wonder, for Satan himself masquerades as an angel of light."




Thank you for watching out for us
Thank you for the heads up m