Every Christian writer on Substack knows this moment. You wrote the article, rewrote it, and edited it until you were sick of looking at it. You moved one comma four times. Finally, you got every line right where you wanted it.
Then comes the anxiety and the questions in your head before clicking publish:
Will they like it?
How many unsubscribes will I get?
Will I be attacked in the comments?
Maybe I shouldn’t post?
If you’re writing on Substack, we’ve all asked those questions to ourselves. We get it - you want to get your words out there. The words God laid on your heart. The words the Holy Spirit led you to. But there’s the overwhelming fear that your audience won’t like it. Because that’s really what we’re afraid of - if we look deep down. We want to know people will care, or see things from our perspective. We all want to be understood and glorify God in our creative ways.
But can I be blunt for just a second?
Who cares if people don’t like it, seriously. Jesus knew people weren’t going to like what He had to say. He didn’t stress about it. He gave the message anyway.
The crowd came for the bread
In John 6, we see one of the biggest crowds in the Gospels.
Jesus takes five loaves of bread and two small fish and feeds about 5,000 men (John 6:9-10). The next morning, the crowd crosses the lake to see Him again (6:24).
In Substack terms, that’s basically a lead magnet.
Some of your readers came in the same way. That might have been a collab, notes, or some sort of giveaway perhaps. That’s fine. Feed them anyway. That’s what Jesus did. What Jesus didn’t do was build His ministry around keeping them fed.
And sometimes, a crowd that comes for bread leaves when the bread runs out.
The hard saying that cleared the room.
Then Jesus says something that cost Him the crowd. The part where He called Himself the bread of life (6:35), then tells them to eat flesh and drink His blood (6:53-56). Some of his own disciples grumbled at this, “This is a hard saying, who can hear it?” (6:60). But Jesus knew what they were whispering (6:61), and He doesn’t take back a word.
The posts that lose you the most readers are usually the ones closest to the Gospel. That could be a number of things. You know the ones. The topics everyone is afrad to write on: sin, the cross, Jesus being the only way, hell…etc. The same goes for the post where you finally admit what you struggled with last year.
But not every unsubscribe is persecution. Jesus offended people with the truth, yes. But He never offended anyone with a snippy remark or attitude. Before you publish, reread it and ask yourself it it’s hard or just harsh. Leave the snarky attitude out and keep the Scripture.
The followers Jesus didn’t chase
Now look at this verse:
“From that time many of his disciples went back, and walked no more with him.”
— John 6:66
Many of His disciples walked away. So what did Jesus do? He didn’t chase after them. He turned to the twelve and asked, “Will ye also go away?” (6:67).
What does that mean for us? Spend your energy on the people who are already with you on Substack. Stop chasing the ones who never cared what you had to say.
I’ve been on Substack for two years, and I’m guilty of obsessing over my dashboard. What I’ve learned is that the relationships are the rewarding part: talking with your readers, replying to their comments, and building each other up. The rest of it... the conversions, the subscriber count, the growth... follows the relationships you build.
So check your numbers one day a week, and leave the dashboard closed the other six.
And remember what Jesus said:
“But seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you.”
— Matthew 6:33
The twelve who stayed
Peter answers for the group, and it’s the best reply in the whole chapter, and it’s also one of my favorite verses.
“Lord, to whom shall we go? thou hast the words of eternal life” (6:68). The teaching was just as hard for Peter as it was for everyone who walked out. He stayed anyway, because he couldn’t find those words anywhere else. (And one of the twelve was Judas, 6:70–71, so don’t expect a perfect list either.)
Think about the people on your list who stay. That could be the woman who replies to every post or the pastor who forwarded your essay to his Wednesday small group. The reader who restacked you with “I needed this today,” that’s who you’re writing for.
Also, side-note, thank you for this encouragement today Heaven Blog (Julie Bonn Blank)!!
So remember, thousands ate the bread, but only twelve carried the Gospel to the world.
Before you hit publish
Ask yourself three questions. Is it true? Is it kind? Will the people who stay walk away fed?
If the answer is yes to all three, hit publish and close the dashboard.
— Thomas M. Hamilton





The twelve who stayed. I’m going to repeat that to myself a million times going forward. Thank you.
I know the feeling, every article I post, it's the same, I think about it before I publish, go back, fix it up, even at times wait a day or 2 afterwards to post. Quite annoying if you ask me haha.
I did enjoy the read and thanks for the encouragement 😊